| D3Wrestle.com Wrestler of the Year |
| Name |
Year |
| Nazar Kulchytskyy |
2013, 2014 |
| NCAA Division III Champion |
| Name |
Weight
|
Year |
| Nazar Kulchytskyy |
157 |
2012, 2014 |
| |
165 |
2013 |
| NCAA Division III All-America |
| Name |
Weight
|
Year |
Finish |
| Mark Choinski |
157 |
2017 |
Sixth |
| |
157 |
2018 |
Fifth |
| |
165 |
2019 |
Third |
| Adam Dorner |
174 |
2007 |
Eighth |
| Joel Dziedzic |
149 |
1999 |
Eighth |
| Duane Fischer |
190 |
1986 |
Third |
| Rick Gruber |
118 |
1981 |
Fourth |
| |
118 |
1982 |
Second |
| |
118 |
1983 |
Third |
| |
118 |
1984 |
Fifth |
| Bill Kahle |
167 |
1996 |
Fourth |
| Nazar Kulchytskyy |
157 |
2012, 2014 |
Champion |
| |
165 |
2013 |
Champion |
| Sean McCarthy |
167 |
1982 |
Second |
| Mike Meunier |
142 |
1994 |
Seventh |
| Dan Schiferl |
174 |
2014 |
Fourth |
| Rich Tomaszewski |
142 |
1982, 1983 |
Seventh |
| NAIA Champion |
| Name |
Weight
|
Year |
| Rick DeMarais |
158 |
1975 |
| NAIA All-America |
| Name |
Weight
|
Year |
Finish |
| Gary Ader |
150 |
1978 |
Fourth |
| Rick DeMarais |
158 |
1975 |
Champion |
| |
158 |
1976 |
Third |
| Ron Dworak |
142 |
1972 |
Fifth |
| |
142 |
1974 |
Third |
| Blaine Felsman |
Heavyweight |
1977 |
Fifth |
| |
Heavyweight |
1978 |
Fourth |
| Stan Kellenberger |
134 |
1979 |
Fourth |
| Mark Mulqueen |
167 |
1970 |
Fifth |
| Joe Semrad |
115 |
1964 |
Sixth |
| Vern Soeldner |
Heavyweight |
1970 |
Fourth |
| Joel Stolzman |
134 |
1977 |
Fifth |
| |
142 |
1979 |
Second |