| NCAA Division III Player of The Year (ABCA) (4) |
| Name |
Position |
Year |
| Chris DeLarwelle |
Third Base |
1990 |
| Tim Jorgensen |
Shortstop |
1994, 1995 |
| Vince Mancuso |
Outfield |
2003 |
| NCAA Division III Rawlings Gold Glove (ABCA) (2) |
| Name |
Position |
Year |
| Brad Demmin |
First Base |
2008 |
| Jake Surane |
Outfield |
2025 |
| Gold Glove selections started with the 2007 season |
| NCAA Division III All-America (ABCA) (67) |
| Name |
Position |
Year (Team) |
| Jeff Carl |
Shortstop |
1979 (Second), 1981 (First) |
| Brian Cashore |
Outfield |
1986 (Third) |
| Troy Cota |
Pitcher |
1985 (Third) |
| Chris DeLarwelle |
Third Base |
1989 (First), 1990 (First) |
| Tom Gardner |
Shortstop |
1991 (Second) |
| Don Garvey |
Second Base |
1991 (First) |
| Mike Gasper |
Pitcher |
1994 (Third) |
| Tom Gessner |
Outfield |
2000 (Third) |
| Craig Glysch |
Pitcher |
1998 (First), 1999 (Third) |
| Kevin Grater |
Pitcher |
1998 (Third) |
| Mark Gullickson |
Pitcher |
1988 (Third) |
| Craig Henderson |
Pitcher |
1981 (First) |
| Steve Hopfensperger |
Pitcher |
1991 (Third) |
| Tom Jaremko |
Outfield |
1983 (First), 1984 (First) |
| Jeremy Jirschele |
Second Base |
2004 (First), 2005 (First) |
| Terry Jorgensen |
Outfield |
1985 (Second), 1986 (First), 1987 (First) |
| Tim Jorgensen |
Shortstop |
1994 (First), 1995 (First) |
| Bobby Kachel |
Outfield |
2013 (Second) |
| Tyler Kamps |
Second Base |
2013 (Third) |
| Andy Kimball |
Pitcher |
1996 (Second), 1997 (First) |
| Casey Kopitzke |
Catcher |
1998 (Second), 1999 (First) |
| Chad Kopitzke |
Pitcher |
1992 (First) |
| Rusty Kryzanowski |
Third Base |
1986 (Second) |
| Craig Lieder |
First Base |
1995 (First) |
| Aaron Luepke |
Third Base |
1998 (Second) |
| Vince Mancuso |
Outfield |
2003 (First) |
| Scott Mann |
Outfield |
1993 (Third) |
| Pat McDonald |
Designated Hitter |
1987 (Third) |
|
Third Base |
1988 (Second) |
|
Outfield |
1989 (Third) |
| Dan Miller |
Shortstop |
1986 (First) |
| Kevin Mlodik |
Pitcher |
1995 (Second) |
| Erik Morrell |
Outfield |
1997 (Second), 1998 (Second) |
| Sean Parnell |
Outfield |
1999 (Second) |
| Phil Pelky |
Outfield |
1981 (First) |
| Kevin Reichardt |
Shortstop |
1985 (Third), 1987 (First) |
| Aaron Richartz |
Third Base |
1992 (First), 1993 (Third), 1994 (First) |
| Matt Scherrman |
Shortstop |
2023 (Third) |
| Bruce Schreiber |
Shortstop |
1988 (Third) |
| Eric Servais |
Third Base |
2000 (Third) |
| Hunter Staniske |
Second Base |
2021 (Second) |
| Bob Stocker |
Pitcher |
1985 (First) |
| Rusty Tiedemann |
First Base |
1987 (Second) |
| Jordan Timm |
Pitcher |
2003 (First) |
| Colan Treml |
Pitcher |
2018 (Third) |
| Jarrod Washburn |
Pitcher |
1995 (Second) |
| Luke Westphal |
Pitcher |
2011 (Third) |
| Tony Wilber |
First Base |
1982 (First), 1983 (Second) |
| Dan Wnuk |
Second Base |
1984 (Second) |
| Ned Yost |
First Base |
2005 (Second) |
| Jeff Zappa |
Outfield |
1995 (Second), 1996 (First) |
| NCAA Division III All-America (D3baseball.com) (4) |
| Name |
Position |
Year (Team) |
| Tyler Kamps |
Second Base |
2013 (Third) |
| Matt Scherrman |
Shortstop |
2023 (Third) |
| Hunter Staniske |
Second Base |
2021 (Second) |
| Luke Westphal |
Pitcher |
2011 (Second) |
| NAIA All-America (11) |
| Name |
Position |
Year |
| Dave Christman |
Pitcher |
1969 (Honorable Mention), 1970 (Honorable Mention) |
| Brian Felda |
Outfield |
1971 (First Team), 1972 (Second Team) |
| Jim Gantner |
Shortstop |
1973 (Honorable Mention) |
| Mark Hinske |
Outfield |
1973 (Honorable Mention) |
| Pete Koupal |
Catcher |
1973 (Honorable Mention) |
| Dave Melum |
First Base |
1970 (Honorable Mention) |
| Andy Pascarella |
Second Base |
1976 (Honorable Mention) |
| Rich Schroeder |
Second Base |
1968 (Honorable Mention) |
| Lee Wyngaard |
Catcher |
1976 (Second Team) |
| NCAA Division III Coach Of The Year (2) |
| Name |
Year |
| Tom Lechnir |
1994 |
| Russ Tiedemann |
1985 |
| NAIA Coach Of The Year (1) |
| Name |
Year |
| Russ Tiedemann |
1974 |
